Sep 18, · Very thoughtful, Kyle, and thanks for bringing Walter Benjamin’s illuminating essay to the fore. As a child of the 20th century I have often wondered why people turned to posting their personal memorabilia online in the first place—as opposed to keeping their artifacts to themselves, to be shared selectively and in person The scheme of buying a spring pig in blossom time, feeding it through summer and fall, and butchering it when the solid cold weather arrives, is a familiar scheme to me and follows an antique pattern Nov 24, · A first class in my dissertation how long is the common app essay supposed to be pradushan ki samasya ka essay, nurses reflective essay: ahmad corbitt a personal essay on race and the priesthood. A family picnic essay for class 3 accounting dissertation topics , starting of a
Death of a Pig, an Essay by E. B. White - The Atlantic
Hi everyone! This missive contains a recap of my columns on digital culture for The New Yorker and a B-side essay that helped personal essay on death figure out my column on how social-media interfaces manipulate us.
The essay is also related to the themes of my upcoming book on algorithmic culture, Filterworldand engages with one of its heroes, the 20th-century critic Walter Benjamin.
Send me any thoughts! The Poetic Misunderstandings of A. Art : A. Ivermectin, the Crate Challenge, and Runaway Memes : What do horse medicine as a COVID cure and falling from a pile of crates have in common? The lawsuit result means the digital economy will be a little more open, personal essay on death. I am rearranging my music collection — looking at the album covers, hearing snippets of the songs in my head as I see personal essay on death one and recall the memories attached to it.
There are the albums I listen to all the time and then those I only pick up once in a while so as not to dull their effects. Actually, it might be more correct to say that my record collection has been rearranged for me: I opened the Spotify app on my laptop a few weeks ago and found that everything I had saved was in disarray. Spotify had updated its interface and suddenly I was lost. The sudden lack of spatial logic was like a form of aphasia, as if someone had moved around all the furniture in my living room and I was still trying to navigate it as I always had.
The next tab over offered personal essay on death, which I never listened to on the app. Nothing made sense. We store books on bookshelves, mount art on our living-room walls, and keep stacks of vinyl records. When we want to experience something, we seek it out, finding a book by its spine, pulling an album from its case, or opening an app.
Where we store something can even outweigh the way we consume it. In the essay, Benjamin narrates removing his book collection from dusty crates, untouched for years. They sat proudly on his shelves as symbols, representing the knowledge that he still aspired to gain or the cities he had traveled, where he encountered a book in a previously unknown shop.
Collecting books was his way of interacting with the world, of building a worldview. My relationship to music is ultimately dictated by the Spotify platform, both what I can listen to and how I listen to it, personal essay on death. They display books or albums and you can choose from among the displayed options in a relatively neutral way. These changes leave no trace; unlike an outdated television or microwave, once the digital app updates itself the older version ceases to exist, smoothly replaced as if it were never there in the first place an erasure that lends a peculiar ephemerality to our memories of technology, personal essay on death.
The biggest change on Instagram circa was the replacement of the button at the bottom center of the screen. The personal essay on death of the platform was no longer creation, building your own set of images, but consumption, passively watching videos, personal essay on death. But I have hit the button by accident many times and recoiled in shock when some dance routine set to loud pop music pops up.
Should I still post mundane snapshots, or do I need to learn a meme dance? My personal Instagram archive, a decade-long account of my adult life in images, still exists on the platform, but that album of memories feels defunct, relic of an earlier era of the software.
My lostness comes from the sense that our personal essay on death collections are not wholly our own anymore. And this lack of agency is undermining our connections to the culture that we love, personal essay on death. For Benjamin, personal essay on death, the importance of collecting stemmed from its endurance and persistence, a longterm commitment that the collector makes to the collection.
You can accrue a delicately curated digital library of music only to have it thrown into disarray when the app changes. Or your collections can be lost entirely when it shuts down. Just as each new digital interface erases its earlier versions, the disappearance of particular apps throws the meaning of content gathered on the app to the wind.
Such is the feeling I get when I look back at my accounts on platforms like Tumblr, where I once collected pages of anime GIFs, fragments of poems, and evocative video game screenshots for the better part of a decade, or the photo albums I posted on Facebook arounda feature that is more or less gone, at least from its original purpose of publishing actually impromptu photos of your friends.
The shifting sands of digital technology have robbed these collections of their meaning; the context in which they originally existed can no longer be experienced and they only appear as nostalgic ruins, the remains of once-inhabited metropolises gone silent. Many of the images I once shared on Tumblr are now personal essay on death links. Algorithmic feeds are by their nature impersonal, though they promise personalized recommendations.
The responsibility of collecting has been removed, but that means we offload it to the black box of the automatic recommendation system. Over the past two decades, the collecting personal essay on death culture — like maintaining a personal library — has moved from being a necessity to a seemingly indulgent luxury, personal essay on death. As a teenager in the s, my on-demand access to music was contained within one of those rubbery CD binders in which you slot albums into transparent cases, like pages in a book.
I flipped through them aimlessly when deciding what to play on my portable discman, my range of choices limited to what I already owned but also deepened because I had a relationship to every disc in the binder. I still have nostalgic memories of that binder; I can feel the texture of the case and the sense of possibility that it held in my mind. Yet that relationship has become increasingly abstract and indirect as the expansion of digital technology in our daily lives has accelerated.
From CD binders I moved to audio players like iTunes, where I still maintained a collection of MP3s, scrolling through them to find a particular musician or album. Then came larger online platforms like YouTube and Pandora, where you could look up videos or songs whenever you wanted but also let the platform create a feed for you, a digital radio station curated by algorithm.
Finally, in recent years, Spotify became the single international behemoth of mainstream music, an unavoidable iceberg of content. You can save or bookmark albums on Spotify and call up a musician to listen to, but the structure of the service drives you toward passive listening, following its recommendations without having to make decisions.
In the era of the algorithmic feed, these platforms have become the containers for our cultural artifacts as well as for our cultural experiences. While we have the advantage of freedom of choice, the endless array of options often instills a sense of meaninglessness: I could be listening to anything, so why should any one thing be important to me? The constructive relationship between consumer and culture goes in both directions, personal essay on death.
When we find something meaningful enough to save, to collect it, the action both etches it a little deeper into our hearts and it also creates a context around the artifact itself, whether song, image, or video — and context not just for ourselves but for other people, the shared context of culture at personal essay on death. Yet even with all its excesses of content, our era of algorithmic feeds might herald the actual death of the collector, because the algorithm itself is the collector, curator, and arbiter of culture.
The placelessness and self-erasure of digital platforms and the enforced passivity of the algorithmic feed have removed these experiences. Click the link we sent toor click here to log in. Thanks for writing this. The cultural shift from active to passive engagement with music or all art is notable and unfortunate, personal essay on death.
There are obvious benefits of something like Spotify, which a tech-optimist would be quick to point out: the ability to discover more new things, the convenience. And we've seemingly made that collective choice. So then we have to ask ourselves whether the convenience principle outweighs the benefits Benjamin is talking about.
And even if we think it doesn't, how can we ever go the opposite direction? Personal reckoning and lifestyle change? Or can we collectively somehow overcome the tidal force of convenience as the presumed "most important thing"?
As a child of the 20th century I have often wondered why people turned to posting their personal memorabilia online in the first place—as opposed to keeping their artifacts to themselves, to be shared selectively and in person. Some people started posting photos of family events to FB to get them out personal essay on death the event participants faster.
It seemed to shorten the distance among family members, personal essay on death, both in time and place. That really felt good.
That I can understand. But to me it seems something changed along the way, such that the event, the lived experience, became subordinated to the posting. The services offer us extraordinary consumer convenience and choice. But convenience always has its costs, some of which turn out to be hidden and unexpected. And painful. Kyle Chayka Industries Subscribe Sign in. About Archive Help Sign in. Share this post.
Essay: The digital death of collecting How platforms mess with our tastes. Kyle Chayka. The Digital Death of the Collector. Create your profile. Only paid subscribers can comment on this post Already a paid subscriber? Log in. Check your email For your security, we need to re-authenticate you. Expand full comment. Nancy Roth. Top New Community What is Kyle Chayka Industries? Ready for more?
See privacyterms and information collection notice. Kyle Chayka Industries is on Substack — the place for independent writing. Our use of cookies We use necessary cookies to make our site work.
We also set performance and functionality cookies that help us make improvements by measuring traffic on our site. For more detailed information about the cookies we use, please see our privacy policy. This site requires JavaScript to run correctly. Please turn on JavaScript or unblock scripts. Sep Comment Skyler Writes Long Press · Sep 20 Thanks for writing this. Expand full comment 6 Reply.
Expand full comment 5 Reply.
Unit Three: The Art of the Personal Essay
, time: 4:31Personal development plan essay
Nov 24, · A first class in my dissertation how long is the common app essay supposed to be pradushan ki samasya ka essay, nurses reflective essay: ahmad corbitt a personal essay on race and the priesthood. A family picnic essay for class 3 accounting dissertation topics , starting of a Sep 18, · Very thoughtful, Kyle, and thanks for bringing Walter Benjamin’s illuminating essay to the fore. As a child of the 20th century I have often wondered why people turned to posting their personal memorabilia online in the first place—as opposed to keeping their artifacts to themselves, to be shared selectively and in person The scheme of buying a spring pig in blossom time, feeding it through summer and fall, and butchering it when the solid cold weather arrives, is a familiar scheme to me and follows an antique pattern
No comments:
Post a Comment